Methodist Cemetery
Also known as Olde Methodist Cemetery and Lincoln Street Cemetery
Westerville, Blendon Township, Franklin County, Ohio
Earliest burial indexed: 1815

West Lincoln Street, Westerville, Ohio
(Map)

This document is a project of
Central Ohio Grave Search


NameDate of Birth Year of BirthDate of Death Year of DeathRemarks

_____, _____

__ Aug

____

[Broken stone]

_____, _____

__ Jul

1856

[Broken stone]

_____, _____

01 Jul

1920

Scratched into the reverse side of the marker for Julia Ann Sharp are what look like initials run together, possibly J M I ?

_____, Abigail

1851

_____, Ama Lawic___?

(illegible)

_____, John

_____, Lewis

_____, Louisa

___inson, _____

10 Aug

1865

_on ___ of __ & A.E. ____inson, aged 6y 6m 10d

Adams, George W.

2_ Mar

1870

Son of P. & M. Adams, aged 21y 9m

Adams, Henry

07 Dec

1857

Son of P. & M. Adams, aged 2y

Adams, John F.

07 Dec

1868?

Son of P. & M. Adams, aged 15y 9m 1d. Date of death may be 1869

Adams, Maggie

28 Aug

1866

Daughter of P. & M. Adams, aged 13?y 21d

Adams, Mary

27 Sep

1870

Wife of Peter, aged 52y 2m 22d

Adams, Mary E.

05 Jul

1871

Wife of John Riley, aged 26y (illegible)

Adams, Minnie R. (B)

11 Aug

1868?

Daughter of P. & M. Adams, aged 22y 1m 11d. Date of death may be 1865

Adams, Peter

29 Mar

1871

Aged 55y 1m 7d

Alexander, Charlotte E.

31 Mar

1824

18 Jan

1901

(Grandmother)

Alexander, Thomas J.

31 Aug

1824

20 Feb

1911

(Grandfather) U.S. Veteran

Arnold, Lucretia

20 Nov

1816

03 May

1906

Baker, Mandy

29 Jul

1865

Wife of Henry Baker, aged 81y 6m 11d

Baker, Nancy

1865

Bell, James

28? Jun

1851

Son of Wm. & Nancy Bell, aged 10y __ __

Bell, John

[Illegible]

Bell, Nancy

17 Jun

1816

20 Nov

1880

Wife of William Bell

Bell?, Lew?

(matches Bell stone)

Benton, Benjamin F.

1851

Benton, Emma

20 Jun

1848?

Daughter of B.E. & M. Benton, aged 1y 11m 10d. Date of death could be 1818

Bishop, Clinton

05 Jun

1857?

Son of John & Sarah Bishop, aged 8y. Date of death may be 1837

Bishop, Jane Adell

15 Sep

1821

31 Mar

1844

Daughter of John & Sarah Bishop, aged 22y 6m 16d

Bishop, John

U.S. Veteran

Bishop, John Jr.

[Stone sunk]

Bosworth, Olive

18 Apr

1849

Wife of John Bosworth, aged 51y 6m 3d

Brinkerhoff, Hetty L.

08 Jan

1870

Wife of Stephen Brinkerhoff, aged 35y

Brinkerhoff, Stephen

Co C 133rd Ohio Infantry, Civil War

Budd, Catharine

09 Mar

1861

Wife of Nicholas Budd, aged 78y

Budd, Daughter

Budd, Emma L.

09 Sep

1883?

11 Jan

1889

Child of J.D. & M.W. Budd

Budd, George L.

08 Jun

1844

Son of John & Violanta Budd, aged 21d

Budd, Grant

29 Mar

1860?

Son of L.W. & A.E. Budd, aged 2y 2m 15d

Budd, John O.

03 Dec

1875

28 Feb

1888

Child of J.D. & M.W. Budd

Budd, Lavina

28 Jul

1894

Aged 75y 1m 27d

Budd, Little

28 Jul

1869

Daughter of J.D. & M.W. Budd

Budd, Nicholas

01 Jun

1867

Aged 93y 1m 27d

Budd, Roley (Rolly) M.

23 Aug

1873

15 Jun

1878

Child of J.D. & M.W. Budd

Budd, Sylvenus

14 Sep

1885

Aged 73y 5m 19d

Campbell, Davis (David)

19 Apr

1844

Aged 76y 4m 6d

Carver, John W.

01 Jan

1864

Aged 39y 8m

Charles Idker

1851

Clark, Catharine (Catherine)B.

01? Apr

1872?

Wife of William Clark, aged 32?y 3m 28d

Clark, George O.

29 Apr

1844

Son of J.P. & Elizabeth Clark, aged 16m

Clark, J. P.

12 Jul

1850

Aged 35y

Clark, Marsella E.

1843

Clark, T. R.

Aged 2y 7m

Conklin, Carrie J.

30 Jun

1879

Aged 38y 7m 11d

Conklin?, David

Jan?

1863

Aged 33y 6m 3d

Connelly, James

1857

Cook, Smith C.

24 Oct

1869

Son of __ & G.B. Cook, aged 1m 7d

Coppedge, Charles D.

12 Feb

1881

Aged 96y

Coppedge, Cyrus

03 Dec

1855

Son of Charles & Sarah, aged 17y 5m 3d

Coppedge, Sarah

11 Jul

1860

Wife of C.D. Coppedge, aged 66y

Cornell, Angeline C.

12 May

1869

Wife of Elias Cornell, aged 62y 8m 8d

Cornell, Elias

12 Aug

1844

(Father) Aged 42y

Cornell, Eliza A.

03 Jul

1844

Daughter of E. & A.C. Cornell, aged 18y 4m 29d

Crist, A. B.

21 Apr

1813

28 Feb

1899

Crist, Martha

13 Mar

1875

Aged 86y 9m 29d

Davis, Willie H.

07 Sep

1860

Son of D.W. & L.A. Davis, aged 1y 10m 4d

Dickson, Nancy

27 Nov

1863

Aged 89y 8m

Dill, Ann M.

10 Oct

1849

Wife of James Dill, aged 42y

Durant, J. C.(S.G.)

Cpl Co H 95th Ohio Infantry

Dusenberry, Charles A.

20 Mar

1877

Aged 26y 5m 22d

Dusenberry, Charles L.

03 Mar

1937

Pvt (Ohio) 23rd Infantry, World War I

Dusenberry, Eddie E.

15 Oct

1871

Son of G.S. & J.P.C., aged 1y 9m 23d

Dusenberry, Nellie

1853

1935

Dusenbury, George S.

24 Aug

1825

26 Jan

1900

Dusenbury, Phoebe C.

29 Nov

1832

16 Jan

1895

Dyxon, Lovett T.

26 Sep

1881

Aged 28y 1m 26d

Eggleston, _____ (illegible)

Child of H.W. & M. Eggleston, aged 6m 13d. Reading by Melissa Killeya indicates date of death 1835 for one of the Eggleston markers with no first name listed

Eggleston, _____ (illegible)

Child of H.W. & M. Eggleston. Reading by Melissa Killeya indicates date of death 1835 for one of the Eggleston markers with no first name listed

Eggleston, David V.

21 Apr

1886

Son of H.W. & M. Eggleston, aged 3y 11m 13d

Eggleston, H. W.

24 Dec

1876

Aged 37y 6m 28?d

Elliott, A. M. G.

19 Mar

1861

Aged 59y 1m 25d

Elliott, Henry

27 Jul

1846

Son of A.M.G. & M. Elliott, aged 20m

Elliott, Julia A.

17 Mar

1808

05? May

1838

Wife of A. ___ M.G., Elliott, aged 50y, born Haddain? Conn, d. Blendon, Ohio

Elliott, Margaret

29 Aug

1866

Wife of A.M.G. Elliott, aged 54y 8m

Elliott, Samuel A.

02 Sep

1846

Son of A.M.G. & M. Elliott, aged 8y

Emery, Clarissa

12 Nov

1784?

18 Oct

1815?

Emery, Clarrissa

12 Nov

1782

18 Dec

1845

Aged 63y 1m 6d. Born Middletown, Ohio

Emery, Nathan Rev.

1819

[Illegible]

Emery, Novella

1815

Enson, A. E.

1865

Evans, Oscar F.

04 Apr

1850

Son of J. & D. Evans, aged 3y 10m

Follon, Eliza Jane

07 Sep

1848

Daughter of A.C. & Mary Follon, aged 1y 7m 1?

Follow, Eliza Jane

1848

Fry, Angeline

01 Dec?

1832?

Daughter of William H. & A. Fry, aged 1m __. Date of death may be 1852

Fry, Henry

_____ brother _____ (illegible)

Fry, Mahlon

23 Nov

1835

05 Apr

1863

Son of William H. & A. Fry. Co G 15th Reg ___, Civil War

Fry, Wesley

09 Oct

1867

Aged 28y 2m 13

Fry, William

1_ Aug

1854?

Son of William H. & A. Fry, aged 9m 8d. Date of death may be 1851

Getzendanner, _____

1862

___ of J.M. & ___ Getzendanner

Getzendanner, Ella

27 Dec

1854

19 Jan

1872

Getzendanner, Harriet

Wife of Josiah (may be top piece of broken stone with date of Feb 1847)

Getzendanner, Josiah

25 Dec

1806

19 Jan

1887

Getzendanner?

Feb

1847

Aged 43y 9m 9d (broken)

Goodspeed, Abigail

21? Sep

1854

Wife of A.G. Goodspeed, aged 32y 26d

Goodspeed, Eunice

09 Jul

1864

Wife of S. Goodspeed, aged 64y 10m 20d

Goodspeed, Lennington W.

03 Sep

1843

Son of L.R. & Rebecca Goodspeed, aged 5m - (stone sunk)

Goodspeed, Phebe Adelia (Adela)

24 Dec

1844

Daughter of Albert & Abigail Goodspeed, aged 11m 5d

Goodspeed, Stephen

02 Mar

1856

Aged 67y 4m 21d

Hagar, Jennie A.

18 Sep

1871

Daughter of L.P. & G.L Hagar, aged 12y 8m 9d

Hagar, John

28 Jul

1870

Aged 90y 5m

Hagar, Lewis V.

03 Dec

1849

Son of Luther P. & Sarah A. Hagar, aged 3m 2d

Hagar, Mary

09 Jan

1869

Wife of John Hagar, aged 81y 5m 13d

Hagar, Sarah Ann

21 Oct

1849

Aged 20y 9m 25d

Hall, Eliak___

12 Sep

1848

Son of D. & N. Hall, aged 5y 1m 3d

Hall, Fanny E.

29 Sep

1848?

Daughter of D. & N. Hall, aged 2y 9m. Date of death could be 1818

Hanthorn, Anna Maria

1851

Hays, Eunice S. Hubbard

Wife of Brice Hays (stone broken)

Hays, W. B.

Sgt Co L 1st NY _____, Civil War

Headington, David

1895

Headington, Ira B.

27 Mar

1860?

Aged 11d. Date of death may be 1862

Headington, Jane A.

15 Aug

1888

Wife of D. Headington, aged 71y 2m

Headington, Jane A.

06 Sep

1895

(Father) Aged 82y 10m 14d

Headington, William

30 Aug

1864

Aged 21y 3m 29d. Died at Andersonville, Civil War

Hempstead, _____

__ Sep

18__

Wife of W. H. Hempstead. Buried?Married?--Feb?Sep?

Ingalls, Alice Iowa

22 Apr

1849?

05 Nov

1850

Born Portsmouth, Ohio, died Maysville, Kentucky, child of Pearl & Mary Ingalls

Ingalls, Ann Mariah (Maria)

29 Jan

1846

Wife of J.B. Ingalls, aged 31y 1m 10d

Ingalls, Belinda C.

21 Nov

1874

Daughter of J.B. & A.M. Ingalls, aged 22y 4m 9d

Ingalls, Pearl Pursell

17 Jul

1851

01 Sep

1852?

Born Haysville, Kentucky, died Chillicothe, Ohio, child of Pearl & Mary Ingalls. Date of death may be 1832

Ingalls, Sally

13 Apr

1855

Wife of Thomas Ingalls, aged 64y

Ingalls, Thomas

11 Jan

1791

24 Sep

1869

Judy, Margareta

1851

Kiser, Catherine

1816

1859

Kiser, Mattie E.

1845

1896

Knox, John _____

02 Jan

1860

Son of L & A.? Knox, aged 2y 8m 16?d

Marsella, F.

19 Feb

1843

Daughter of J.P. & Elizabeth Clark, aged 20m

Mason, Josiah

04 J_n

1864

Son of A._. & A.E. Mason, aged 8?y 7m 11d

Meacham (Meagham), Mary Jane

10 Mar

1865

Wife of Lawrence L. Meacham, aged 33y 3m 14d

Meacham, Riley E.

08 Aug

1857

Son of M.M. & A.A. Meacham, aged 8m

Mead, Ann Hunt

20 Feb

1875

Wife of L. Mead, aged 80y 9m

O'Neal, Elizabeth

24 Dec

1819?

Wife of Henry O'Neal. Date of death could bathing and dressing 1849

Park, Agusta E.

1854

Park, David

12 Mar

1861

Son of A. & S. Park, aged 32y 3m 2d. Civil War Veteran

Park, William H. (W.H.H.H.)

26 May

1862

Son of A. & S. Park, aged 22y 1m 1d. Died in US Service, buried _____, Mississippi, Civil War

Parke, Abner

28 Dec

1798

08 Jun

1880

Son of Abner & Patience Parke

Parke, Cornelia A.

1915

Parke, Sarah Pennal

09 Oct

1802

11 Oct

1899

Wife of Abner Parke

Parker, Abby

30 Jul

1858

Wife of C.? J. Parker, aged 23y 10m 17d

Perkins, _____

1843

Perry, Jacob Ira

18 Jul

1848

Son of George & Margaret, aged 7y 5m 24d

Phijis

1878

Phillips, Hellen

16 Apr

1856

Wife of William Phillips, aged 46y 3m 24d

Phillips, O. B.?

Co F 18th US Infantry

Phillips, Oscar B.

14 Apr

1887

Aged 47y

Price, Sarah C.

08 Sep

1862

Wife of Warrick, aged 26y 5m 6d

Price, Warick (Warrick)

06 Mar?

1864

Aged 33y 7m 9d. Killed iin US Service, buried on Flat Top Mountain, West Virginia, Civil War

Purkins, Thomas Rev.

09 Feb

1809

01 May

1843

Aged 34y 2m 22d

Ranney, Gamra

11 Aug

1867

(Our Little _____) Daughter of J.E. & E. Ranney, aged 1y 17d

Riker, Charles

11 Nov

1856

Afed 30y 4m

Riker, Jane

19 Feb

1864?

Aged 34y Date of death could be 1861

Riker, Margaret A.

24 Nov

1851

Wife of _.A. Judy Riker, aged 24y 5m 22d

Riker, Sarah Ann

09 Sep

1854?

Wife of Jeremiah, aged 67y 22d. Date of death may be 1851

Rinehart, Morgan

30 Nov

1848

Son of Samuel & Olive, aged 2y 5m 7d

Rinehart, Olive

12 Jul

1848

Wife of Samuel, aged 24y 9m 25d

Sammis, Alice

26 Jul

1845?

Aged 10 hours

Sammis, Emerson

02 Apr

1875

Aged 28y 5m 22d

Sammis, Ezra

12 Apr

1838

Aged 49y

Sammis, Ida

04 Mar

18__

Aged 2m _d

Sammis, Lovett

03? Sep

1861?

Aged 1y

Sammis, Martha E.

06 May

1876

Daughter of S.R. & M. Sammis, aged 27y 6m 13d

Sammis, Mary

28? Dec

18__

Wife of S.R.? Sammis, aged 36y 3m

Sammis, Mary T.

__ Jun

1866

Aged __y 3?m 11?d

Sammis, Nancy

03 Oct

1844

Wife of Ezry Sammis, aged 60y

Sammis, Nancy M.

22 Jun

1890?

(Mother) Wife of S.R. Sammis, aged 72y 7m 12d. Date of death may be 1896

Sammis, Selah B.(R.)

09 Apr

1884

Aged 67y 10d

Schrock, Malinda

1853

Scott, Frank

01 Apr

1851

Aged 32y 9m 4d

Scott, Frank

1857

1946

Scott, Mary D.

25 Jul

1853

Wife of S. Scott, aged 31y 11m 3d

Sharp, Andrew

04 Jan

1871

Aged 66y 4m 26d. Civil War Veteran

Sharp, Anna

28 Sep

1857?

Wife of Garrit Sharp, aged 24y. Date of death my be 1852

Sharp, Calestia

14 Dec

1845

Daughter of Cornelius & Harriet Sharp, aged 15y 9m 8d

Sharp, Clinton S.

04 Nov

1888

Aged 5y 7m 18d

Sharp, Garrit

26? Nov

1859?

[Illegible] Date of death may be 1899

Sharp, Hester A.

20 Feb

1894

Wife of S. Sharp, aged 74y 3m 14d

Sharp, Isaac W.

1848

1905

Son of S. & H.A. Sharp

Sharp, John W.

15 Apr

1858

Aged 1m 27d

Sharp, Joseph

30 Mar

1855

Aged 51?y 1?m 21d

Sharp, Julia Ann Dickson

10 Oct

1834?

Daughter of Ambrose & Nancy Dickson & consort of Stephen Sharp, aged 25y. Date of death may be 1851

Sharp, Lewis A.

04 Jun

1845

Aged 1y 7m 20d

Sharp, Mary

11 Sep

184_

[Stone broken]

Sharp, Mary Ann

10 Aug

1814

29 Dec

1905

Sharp, Parthene

11 Feb

1855?

Aged _3y [stone sunk]. Date of death may be 1837

Sharp, Sophene

25 May

1802

24 Sep

1884?

Wife of Jos. Sharp. Date of death may be 1881

Sharp, Stephen

10 May

1886

Aged 79y 17d

Sharp, William

10 Jul

1812

21 Jan

1899

U.S. Veteran

Slight, Elizabeth

19 Aug

1794

14 May

1881

Aged 86y 8m 25d

Spence (Spencer), Isaac

02 Oct

1855

Aged 64y 10m 2d

Spring, Adell

20 Sep

1861

Aged 2y 8m 6d

Spring, Elizabeth

Sep

1834

Sep

1901

Spring, Fredrick (Frederick)

12 Apr

1825

19 Apr

1906

Spring, Hattie M.

22 Mar

1858

Aged 10m 6d

Spring, Henry

20 May

1829

Son of H. & M. Spring, died and buried at Mardions? Point, Connecticut, aged 1y 1m 15d

Spring, Horace

19 Feb

1882

(Father) Aged 81y 9m 11d

Spring, Joann

Daughter of F. & M. Spring (illegible)

Spring, Kate B.

06 Jan

1871

Daughter of C.S. & M.J. Spring, aged 4y 1m 22d

Spring, Martha A.

21 Jun

1861

Wife of F. Spring, aged 27y 11m 18d

Spring, Minerva

09 May

1873

(Mother) Wife of Horace Spring, aged 74y 1m 21d

Stevenson, _____

10 Oct

1856

Son of A.G. & E.A., aged 2y

Sutton, Arba

28 Oct

1849

Aged 20y 4m 8d

Taylor, Lucretia

04 Jan

1886

Wife of Radolphus Taylor, aged 97y

Taylor, Radolphus

14 Mar

1870

Aged 82y

Twain, Jennie O.

1880

Vandruff, John

02 Jul

1818

21 Jan

1897?

Aged 78y 6m 19d. Date of death may be 1837

Vandruff, Ruth

11 May

1834

11 Aug

1886

Vinson, Jesiah

1861

Wambaugh, Hannah

19 Aug

1834?

Wife of P. Wambaugh, aged 31y _____ (broken). Date of death may be 1851

Wambaugh, Paul

12 Oct

1858

Aged 39y 9m 19d

Washburn, Clara E.

26 Apr

1865

Wife of William R. Washburn, aged 27y 2m

Wells, Amon

1838

1903

Westervelt, G.(C.) Lennington

22 Oct

1859

Aged 36y 3m 17d

Westervelt, George F.

1848

Westervelt, Hannah Lennington

28 May

1886

Wife of P. Westervelt, aged 90y 2m 13d

Westervelt, Laura B.

1859

1919

Westervelt, Matthew

Aged 29y 6m

Westervelt, Minerva F.

30 Oct

1823

12 Aug

1844

Wife of Edwin, aged 20y 9m 13d

Westervelt, Minerva I.

1823

Westervelt, Peter

08 Aug

1869

Aged 77y 10m 19d

Westervelt, Sally

04 Jun

1796

13 May

1877

Aged 80y 11m 9d

Westervelt, Sophronia B.

25 Dec

1847

Wife of Edwin Westervelt, aged 22y 2m 8d

Westervelt, Sylvinus (Sylvenius) B.

13 Jun

1848

Son of William B. & M.F. Westervelt, aged 1y 2m 16d

Westervelt, William

08 Aug

1792

31 Mar

1878

Aged 85y 7m 22d

Westervelt, William B.

03 Feb

1850?

Aged 28y 7m 23d. Date of death may be 1820

Wilkinson, Flora

08? Sep

1854

Daughter of R.P. & N.I.? Wilkinson, aged 10m

Wilkinson, Zelda

1851

Willcox, William

1875

U.S. Veteran

Wyckoff (Wickoff), Bertha Scott

1889

1956

 

 

Sources:

Franklin County Chapter of The Ohio Genealogical Society (comp.), Franklin County, Ohio Cemeteries, Volume 4, Plain and Blendon Townships, Columbus, December 1981, pages 82-87 (1981 gravestone reading by The Ohio Genealogical Society)

Killeya, Melissa, reading of Olde Methodist Cemetery, unknown date, submitted to US GENWEB file archives website 23 May 2001, accessed 24 Sep 2013 http://files.usgwarchives.net/oh/franklin/cemeteries/old_me.txt


Links of Interest:

City of Westerville Local History - Methodist Cemetery (Link)

 

 

TOP OF PAGE

RETURN TO CEMETERY LIST

HOME